SCO insights

Determining the Right Stock Holding Point for BioTech Downstream European Distribution

Written by Tim Foetisch | Jan 22, 2025 7:51:38 AM

Downstream distribution plays a critical role in ensuring that products reach their intended destinations efficiently, compliantly, and safely. Choosing the right stock holding point within a European distribution network involves a thorough evaluation of multiple criteria, encompassing logistical, financial, tax, and quality assurance/regulatory affairs (QA/RA) considerations. Below, we delve into the key factors to consider when determining the optimal stock holding point in a biotech distribution setup.

1. Proximity to Market Demand

A primary driver for selecting a stock holding location is its proximity to end customers, which directly impacts delivery times. Life savers require short distribution leadtime thus often local stock solution. On the other hands, the scarcity of some product for instance in the field of Rare Diseases rather tend to favour a Central European stock.

Considerations:

  • Demand Clusters: Identifying regions with high demand based on patient geographies and channel to market insights.

  • Lead Times: Balancing shorter lead times against the cost of holding inventory closer to customers while taking into account any emergency usage needs..

2. Logistical Infrastructure

The efficiency of transportation and warehousing infrastructure in a chosen location is another key factor. In the BioTech industry, they are limited number of players that offer full pan-European logistics services including Order to Cash capabilities.

Considerations:

  • Transportation Networks: Accessibility to major highways, ports, and airports.

  • Temperature Controlled Capabilities: Availability of facilities to support temperature-controlled storage and transportation, critical for many biotech products.

  • Order to Cash: Experience in taking pan-European orders including cash collection
  • Cross-Border Connectivity: Ensuring seamless movement of goods between EU countries, considering customs clearance and potential non-EU trade (e.g., Brexit implications).

3. Regulatory and QA Considerations

Local regulations can significantly influence the choice of stock holding points. For instance, Switzerland require a local inventory of Finished Product. 

Considerations:

  • Local Stock Requirements: Some countries mandate the presence of specific products within their borders, especially life-saving medications or vaccines. For example, national authorities may require minimum safety stock levels to ensure public health.

  • Qualified Person (QP) Release: EU regulations stipulate that a QP must certify batches before they are released for distribution. Selecting a stock holding point with access to QP services is essential.

  • Regulatory Compliance: Ensuring the facility complies with Good Distribution Practices (GDP) and other relevant local/country-specific guidelines.

4. Cost Considerations

Balancing service levels with cost efficiency is a perennial challenge in supply chain design. In design network, the key equation lies in the mix of warehousing costs vs transportation cost. 

Considerations:

  • Warehousing Costs: Rental and operational costs for storage facilities. Fixed Cost are an important driver in the decision mix.

  • Tax Implications: The overall financial flow must be considered including potential Tax optimization. 

  • Inventory Carrying Costs: Assessing the financial burden of holding stock, including obsolescence risks for biotech products with short shelf lives.

5. Risk Management and Business Continuity

The biotech industry is highly sensitive to disruptions, making risk mitigation a critical factor in stock holding decisions.

Considerations:

  • Redundancy: Diversifying stock holding points to reduce reliance on a single location.

  • Supply Chain Resilience: Ensuring backup transportation routes and alternative suppliers.

6. Scalability and Future Growth

A forward-looking approach is necessary to accommodate growth and changing market dynamics.

Considerations:

  • Facility Expansion Potential: Selecting a stock holding point with room for growth in storage capacity.

  • Market Entry: Positioning inventory closer to emerging markets within Europe.

7. Sustainability and Corporate Responsibility

Sustainability is increasingly a key consideration in supply chain decisions, especially in Europe, where environmental regulations are stringent.

Considerations:

  • Carbon Footprint: Minimizing transportation distances and favoring energy-efficient warehouses.

  • Compliance with EU Green Initiatives: Adhering to policies promoting sustainable logistics practices.

Conclusion

Determining the optimal stock holding point in a BioTech downstream European distribution network requires a nuanced approach that balances logistical efficiency, regulatory compliance, and cost considerations. Incorporating QA/RA requirements, such as local country stock mandates and GDP adherence, ensures both regulatory and operational compliance. By evaluating market demand, infrastructure, risks, and sustainability, one can create robust distribution networks that meet the dual objectives of delivering life-saving products efficiently and maintaining high standards of quality and compliance.

 

Let's discuss about your downstream distribution: